A/B Testing Can Help Transform The Effectiveness Of Employee Training

James Glover (CEO of Flint Learning Solutions) helps HR professionals transform behaviors in their organizations to solve business problems.

Providing professional development opportunities is becoming incredibly important. It consistently ranks among the top factors that influence employees’ opinions of an employer. Companies that invest in employee development often see significant benefits in retention because employees want to know that their growth is supported. Given this clear connection between development and retention, HR and L&D leaders must understand whether their training initiatives truly work.

However, many organizations struggle to demonstrate the effectiveness of their learning programs beyond basic metrics like course completion and satisfaction scores. This disconnect puts L&D in a vulnerable position during budget discussions, especially when other departments can demonstrate clearer ROI.

One solution might come from an unexpected place: digital marketing. The A/B testing methodology that revolutionized marketing analytics offers a framework for proving L&D effectiveness and demonstrating concrete training impact where it matters most—in the 70% of learning that happens on the job.

What Is A/B Testing?

A/B testing involves comparing two slightly different versions of something to determine which performs better against specific metrics. For example, digital marketers may want to test which new email template drives more clicks or which landing page design converts more visitors. So they send Template A to one group and Template B to another, then let the data reveal the winner. Occasionally, they have a control, or holdout, group that doesn’t see either Template A or Template B. Instead, they continue receiving whatever template was in place before.

What makes this approach useful for L&D is its ability to isolate variables and establish causation. When leadership asks, “What’s the ROI on this training program?,” many L&D teams lack compelling answers. But A/B testing can change this dynamic by providing a structured framework to:

• Isolate specific variables in a learning approach

• Establish clear before-and-after measurement points

• Compare outcomes between different approaches

• Connect learning directly to behavior change and business results

Adopting this methodology can transform L&D from a cost center to a strategic business driver with provable impact.

How To Apply A/B Testing

If you’re interested in adopting A/B testing for your L&D programming, here are a few steps to help make you successful.

1. Choose a single variable to test.

Focus on one key aspect at a time, keeping everything else constant. For example, you might want to determine the most effective delivery method (in-person versus virtual) or content sequence (theory first versus practice first). Let’s say you’re hoping to optimize a training that helps managers give better feedback. You may choose to test whether adding on-the-job practice after formal training leads to better skill development than formal training alone.

2. Define clear objectives.

Establish specific goals connected to observable workplace behaviors. Be specific about what behaviors should change and how those connect to business outcomes. For example, if addressing high turnover is one motivator for improving your feedback training, objectives might include increasing the frequency of feedback conversations or improving how constructive feedback is delivered.

3. Select meaningful metrics.

Track behavior change indicators (both self-reported and manager-observed) and business impact metrics. For feedback training, this might include before/after self-assessments, manager observations and team retention rates. Having a holdout group is especially useful in this case because it provides a baseline for comparison that makes your final results more meaningful.

4. Analyze results, then take action.

Look for significant differences between groups, document specific behavior changes and connect these to business metrics. A/B testing’s key advantage is that it facilitates continuous improvement. After analyzing initial results, you can refine training and run further tests. This ensures your approach remains agile and responsive to changing workplace dynamics.

Summary

A/B testing provides talent leaders with a methodology to move beyond traditional learning metrics so they can demonstrate their work’s real-world impact on the bottom line. By adopting this approach from digital marketing, you can definitively prove which training methods drive behavior change, connect initiatives directly to business outcomes and make data-driven decisions about training investments. With this information, you can employ training initiatives that engage employees and actually drive the changes necessary to solve critical business problems.

Forbes Human Resources Council is an invitation-only organization for HR executives across all industries. Do I qualify?